Dear Doctors, Have any of you had success in treating lumbar disk herniation with manipulation? I am treating a 24 year old volunteer fireman now with an L5-S1 medial herniation. He has positive nerve stretch signs in the left leg with pain into the calf, cannot toe walk on the left and has a weak extensor hallusis on the left. His reflexes have remained brisk and he has no changes in bowel or bladder functions. He is opposed to surgery and I agreed to a one month trial of therapy. We use a combination of flexion/distraction and gentle side posture manipulations. He has shown a 50% improvement in the past month using visual analog pain scale and Owestry Questionaire. The managed care company (Liberty Mutual) is pushing for surgery as a "less expensive alternative" to conservative care. For your info, I've attached studies I have supplied to the carrier to make my case for continued conservative therapy. Jerry Vonderharr, DC Evart Chiropractic Clinic vonder@netonecom.net fax: 616-734-6465 phone: 616-734-5891 MEDLINE SEARCH: LUMBAR DISK HERNIATION/ MANIPULATION Stern PJ; Cote P; Cassidy JD A series of consecutive cases of low back pain with radiating leg pain treated by chiropractors. Department of Orthopaedics, Royal University Hospital, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1995 Jul-Aug;18(6):335-42 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 96020510 Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To report the clinical presentation and outcome of consecutive patients who received a course of nonoperative treatment, including manipulation, for low back and radiating leg pain. This review was conducted to generate hypotheses for a future clinical trial involving manipulation for the treatment of lumbar spine disk herniation. DESIGN: A case series of consecutive patients presenting to a postgraduate teaching chiropractic clinic between 1990 and 1993 was evaluated. Three thousand, five hundred and fifty-three charts were reviewed; in 71 of the cases, the patient had low back pain (LBP) with radiating leg pain clinically diagnosed as lumbar spine disk herniation. OUTCOME MEASURES: All outcome measures were extracted from the patients' charts. Subjective improvement reported by the patient, range of motion and nerve root tension signs were used to assess improvement. RESULTS: Of the 59 patients who received a course of treatment, 90% reported improvement of their complaint. A subgroup analysis indicated that 75% of the patients that reported improvement of their conditions had an increase in straight leg raising (SLR) and lumbar range of motion. The maximum complication rate associated with this treatment approach was estimated to be 5% or less. A previous history of low back surgery was a statistically significant predictor of poor outcome. CONCLUSION: Based on our results, we postulate that a course of nonoperative treatment including manipulation may be effective and safe for the treatment of back and radiating leg pain. This hypothesis remains to be tested in a prospective study. Mazanec DJ Back pain: medical evaluation and therapy. Center for the Spine, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, OH 44195, USA. REVIEW ARTICLE: 32 REFS. Cleve Clin J Med 1995 May-Jun;62(3):163-8 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 95330861 Abstract: Most patients with acute low back pain or sciatica improve with appropriate conservative therapy, and most require no immediate diagnostic studies beyond a careful history and examination. In patients with red flags for visceral, malignant, or infectious causes or possible cauda equina syndrome, a more aggressive evaluation is mandatory. In patients whose pain does not respond to initial management or who have chronic symptoms, diagnostic re-evaluation is appropriate. Pustaver MR Mechanical low back pain: etiology and conservative management. Pustaver Chiropractic Care, Matthews, NC 28105. REVIEW ARTICLE: 83 REFS. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1994 Jul-Aug;17(6):376-84 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 95053420 Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To review literature pertaining to low back pain (including lumbar disk herniation) and its treatment by manipulative therapy and rehabilitative exercises. DATA SOURCES: A Medline literature search was performed. English and foreign language materials were reviewed. Key words included the following: manipulation, manipulative therapy, lumbar intervertebral disk herniation, lower back pain. STUDY SELECTION: The studies detailed the neurologic and biomechanical aspects of manipulative therapy, as well as the efficacy of manipulative and rehabilitative management of mechanical low back pain. Also included were studies detailing the etiology of mechanical low back pain. DATA SYNTHESIS: Recent studies have indicated there are certain activities that commonly precipitate lower back injuries. Several methods of treatment for these injuries are discussed. The review indicated the most effective form of treatment is manipulative therapy. The neurologic and biomechanical aspects of manipulation are discussed. CONCLUSION: Low back pain is a common cause of physical, emotional and financial distress. This paper concluded that manipulative therapy is an efficacious as well as cost-effective method of treatment in cases of mechanical low back pain. Schneider MJ Distraction manipulation reduction of an L5-S1 disk herniation [letter; comment] J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1993 Nov-Dec;16(9):618-20 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 94180008 Comment on: J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1993 Jun;16(5):342-6 Cox JM; Hazen LJ; Mungovan M Distraction manipulation reduction of an L5-S1 disk herniation [see comments] J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1993 Jun;16(5):342-6 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 93346925 Comment in: J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1993 Nov-Dec;16(9):618- 20;Comment in: J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1994 Jan;17(1):60-4 Abstract: OBJECTIVE: A computed tomography (CT)-confirmed L5-S1 disk protrusion is reported to be reduced following chiropractic adjustment, as seen on repeat CT scanning. Correlation of the CT reports with the patient's symptoms before and after manipulation is reported. CLINICAL FEATURES: A 38-yr-old female was treated for low back pain and right lower extremity first sacral dermatome sciatica. CT confirmed disk herniations at both the L4-L5 and L5-S1 levels were found. Motor weakness of the right gluteus maximus muscle was found and extremely tight hamstring muscles accompanying positive straight leg signs were elicited. A clinical and imaging diagnosis of an L5-S1 disk herniation was made. INTERVENTION AND OUTCOME: Distraction type chiropractic manipulation, electrical stimulation, exercises, nutrition advice and low back wellness class were administered with complete relief of sciatic pain and nearly complete relief of low back pain. CONCLUSIONS: Chiropractic distraction manipulation is an effective treatment of lumbar disk herniation, if the chiropractor is observant during its administration for patient tolerance to manipulation under distraction and any signs of neurological deficit demanding other types of care. Hession EF; Donald GD Treatment of multiple lumbar disk herniations in an adolescent athlete utilizing flexion distraction and rotational manipulation. Monmouth College Department of Sports Medicine, West Long Branch, NJ. REVIEW ARTICLE: 50 REFS. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1993 Mar-Apr;16(3):185-92 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 93260360 Abstract: An acute case of low back pain in a high school athlete is described. Onset of nonradicular back pain was related to squat-type weightlifting in preparation for high school football. Magnetic resonance images demonstrated central posterior disk herniations with thecal sac effacement of the lower three disk levels. Clinical and electrophysiological evaluation revealed no neurological deficits. Flexion distraction and rotational manipulation with adjunctive paraspinal muscle stimulation resulted in early improvement and apparent long-term resolution of this patient's symptoms. The effectiveness of flexion distraction and rotational manipulation in reducing subjective symptoms are compared utilizing visual analog pain scales. Literature review of the conservative treatment of lumbar disk herniations is discussed. Cassidy JD; Thiel HW; Kirkaldy-Willis WH Side posture manipulation for lumbar intervertebral disk herniation [see comments] Department of Orthopaedics, Royal University Hospital, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada. REVIEW ARTICLE: 41 REFS. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1993 Feb;16(2):96-103 Unique Identifier: MEDLINE 93187577 Comment in: J Manipulative Physiol Ther 1994 May;17(4):258-62 Abstract: OBJECTIVES: The objective of this article is to review the status of side posture manipulation for lumbar intervertebral disk herniation. DATA SOURCES, STUDY SELECTION AND DATA EXTRACTION: The data presented in this article are from our Back Pain Clinic at the Royal University Hospital and the articles cited are those which we feel are important in reviewing this subject. CONCLUSIONS: The treatment of lumbar intervertebral disk herniation by side posture manipulation is both safe and effective. Further research is required to understand more fully the effects of this treatment on the intervertebral disk. | |
|