e99 Online Shopping Mall
Help | |
Home - Basic I - Indigenous Peoples Guatemala (Books) |
  | Back | 61-75 of 75 |
click price to see details click image to enlarge click link to go to the store
61. Our Elders Teach Us : Maya-Kaqchikel Historical Perspectives (Contemporary American Indian Studies) by David Carey Jr., Allan F. Burns | |
Paperback: 400
Pages
(2001-11-13)
list price: US$32.95 -- used & new: US$21.00 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 081731119X Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
62. Spaniards and Indians in Southeastern Mesoamerica: Essays on the History of Ethnic Relations (Latin American Studies) | |
Hardcover: 291
Pages
(1983-11-01)
list price: US$40.00 Isbn: 0803230826 Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
63. The Symbolism of Subordination: Indian Identity in a Guatemalan Town by Kay B. Warren | |
Paperback: 237
Pages
(1989-04)
list price: US$12.95 -- used & new: US$12.95 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0292776217 Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
64. Maya Intellectual Renaissance: Identity, Representation, and Leadership (Linda Schele Series in Maya and Pre-Columbian Studies) by Victor D. Montejo | |
Paperback: 260
Pages
(2005-08-01)
list price: US$19.95 -- used & new: US$14.00 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0292709390 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (1)
Maya Identity |
65. The Tzutujil Mayas: Continuity and Change, 1250-1630 (Civilization of the American Indian) by Sandra L. Orellana | |
Hardcover: 287
Pages
(1984-07)
list price: US$44.95 -- used & new: US$79.95 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0806117397 Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
66. Art and Society in a Highland Maya Community: The Altarpiece of Santiago Atitlán (The Linda Schele Series in Maya and Pre-Columbian Studies) by Allen J. Christenson | |
Paperback: 260
Pages
(2001-12-15)
list price: US$24.95 -- used & new: US$20.00 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0292712421 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (1)
An essential contribution to the Mayanist literature |
67. Maya Revolt and Revolution in the Eighteenth Century (Latin American Realities) by Robert W. Patch | |
Paperback: 280
Pages
(2002-06)
list price: US$36.95 -- used & new: US$26.01 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0765604124 Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description |
68. Rigoberta Menchu and the Story of All Poor Guatemalans: Expanded Edition New Foreword by Elizabeth Burgos by David Stoll | |
Paperback: 384
Pages
(2007-12-25)
list price: US$33.00 -- used & new: US$13.19 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0813343968 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description The expanded edition of this internationally controversial book includes a new foreword from Elisabeth Burgos, the editor of I, Rigoberta Menchú, as well as a new afterword from Stoll, who clarifies his original position and addresses the many controversies and debates that have arisen since the book was first published. "In a peasant society ruled by elders, where girls reaching pubertyare kept under close watch, it would be very unusual for a person ofher age and gender to play the leadership role she describes," Stollwrites. Neither, he argues, was she monolingual and illiterate, as sheclaimed to be; her presentation of self as "noble savage," hecontinues, gave her an unwarranted moral authority when she presentedstories that she had heard from others as if she had been aparticipant. His findings, Stoll notes, do not discount the realviolence visited by the Guatemalan government on its subjects,although they certainly might give comfort to apologists of theregime. (Interestingly, he notes, Menchú has since disavowed portionsof her memoir as the work of the French anthropologist who recordedthem.) --Gregory McNamee Customer Reviews (14)
Great Provocation To Ensure Debate Lasts Forever
Author misses his own point As one who has spent several years living and working among Guatemalans who (barely) survived army massacres, tortures and disappearances, and who was in Guatemala when Stoll's book came out, I find these revelations to hardly be capital crimes. Rigoberta's book was an attempt to bring international attention to the Guatemalan army's genocide campaign against the indigenous population. To that effect it was successful, although not nearly successful enough. Is Menchu's book a perfect account of her life? Apparently not. Is it an accurate portrayal of what happened to millions of other indigenous Guatemalans? The UN-sponsored Truth Commission, and the Catholic Church's REMHI report have definatively answered in the affirmative. In the end, you could say that Rigoberta's book is more accurately the story of "all poor Guatemalans" than it is her own.What Stoll sees as a fault is really one of the book's main virtues. There are many stories that urgently need to be told about Guatemala. That Stoll would choose to spend his professional career attacking someone who has tirelessly fought for the human and cultural rights of Guatemala's indigenous people is the real mystery here. Instead of focusing on Rigoberta Menchu, a marginal, if noble, figure in Guatemala's sad history, why not undo the country's more dangerous mythic figure, Efrain Rios Montt (killed tens of thousands during his 16 month reign of terror, and now currently runs Guatemala's Congress and ruling party). How many as-told-to autobiographies would stand up to 10 years of background checking? Personally, I'm waiting for Stoll's account of his own life story...
Witchhunt: a nasty man in an ivory tower Stoll's argument is three-fold: Firstly, he balks at the Like Dinesh d'Souza's extreme right-wing book Illiberal Education, Stoll's poses a critique of the academic left.Unlike d'Souza's rant, Stoll's book is in turn a fascinating, but infuriating read, but ultimately mean-spirited, academically disingenuous and far from "objective." For example, when Stoll points to debatable discrepancies within the testimony, he offers other voices and political contexts.He interviews people from Menchu's village El Chimel; he interviews I Rigoberta Menchu editor Elisabeth Burgos-Debray and the ambassador who survived the army-induced embassy fire in which Menchu's father ---who along with protesters had taken the ambassador hostage---dies.A chapter is devoted to fragmented interviews with women who allegedly attended a convent school with Menchu.Stollrelishs each detail that invalidates Menchu's claim that, like many other Mayan children, she did not attend formal school and only learned Spanish as she became an activist. In many respects, Stoll's fieldwork seems exhaustive.It starts to pay off when Stoll deviates from his from his attack on Menchu's authenticity to historicize Guatemalan politics and trace the alliances of peasant and indigenous organizations.However, these discussions tend to break down as condemnations --- and conflations --- of Menchu and Marxism.Stoll's motives appear particularly ominous when it is revealed that, despite ten years of work in Guatemala, he listens to a mere two-and-a-half-hours of the eighteen hours of recorded testimony Rigoberta Menchu gives Elisabeth Burgos-Debray.And Stoll was right there in Burgos-Debray's apartment. Many years have passed since the week in 1982 when Menchu, a political refugee, gave oral testimony to the Argentine anthropologist.Until recently, that week long meeting represented most of what the public gleaned about Rigoberta Menchu.Since the testimony concludes at the point of exile, it does not reveal Menchu's constant lobbying for indigenous rights and Guatemalan peace treaties at the UN, prior to winning the Nobel Peaceprize.It is fortunate that months before the Stoll hatchet job, Menchu's own account of her political work, including life after the Peaceprize, and episodes that were obscured in the first work, was published.Stoll's self-serving book should only be read along with its source material and her second book. Considered together, the three books fashion an intriguing matrix of truth-making, of interpretations and re-interpretations that shift based on political circumstance and personal positioning. Still, my fundamental feeling is that Stoll was out to frame Menchu at any cost.It saddens me to see so many people jumping on his bandwagon, serving the purpose of further empowering the wealthy and privileged, and casting doubt on one of the rare voices of Central American indigenous people to reach us.Her story of oppression, resistence and survival is more important than any minor discrepencies Stoll so relishes. Stoll's book is pure careerism and is nasty to the core.Menchu's meaningful life work speaks louder. It inspires while Stoll's knarled intentions digust.
The Myth of Menchu Long before this book appeared I found it odd that I couldn't find a single Guatemalan who believed the popularized story of Menchu. I had doubts myself since the historic highway of leftism is paved with the remains of frauds and tyrants. This book lays my doubts to rest. Menchu is a fraud. She has been used by the Left to bash the U.S., and she used them and a gullible international media to become a star. Menchu is to the misty eyed utopian dreamers what Fabio is to lonely, yearning readers of romance novels, or what Miss February is to adolescent men. Rigoberta is the socialist pin-up girl. But the fantasy of the left always turns violent and ugly. In the Guatemalan case the author also demonstrates that the indians were used as pawns to further the objectives of the Left and their guerilla surrogates. The Left pushed the mostly uninterested indians into the face of the repressive right-wing government while shouting, "they say you are fascists murderers." Wedged between the bloodthirsty Left and Right, the indians got slaughtered. Menchu, like Lenin, Castro, Foucault, and so many before her, is a symbol of the moral corruption of the Left. People drawn to utopian reformism are also ideal candidates for the cult of personality. Menchu became (and still is) a useful invention of those who build castles in sand saturated with the blood of innocents. One thing is certain, this book will cause no general reassessment by the Left. Few leftists will ask themselves, "How did I get taken in by the myth of Menchu?" The Left merely steps over the bodies and havoc it precipitates, moving on to the next big religious crusade. After all, you can't make an omelet without breaking a few eggs, can you? The thousands of innocent Guatemalan eggs cracked in the leftist guerilla warmerely join the millions of others around the world. Yet very few leftists have found that mass murders associated with their beliefs are reason to rethink. Even one prior reviewer of this book reduces his rating because one of the rare leftists who rethought his views has given support to the conclusions of David Stoll. Several thousand people were sadly murdered during the Pinochet regime in Chile, and the Left pursues this relentlessly. Millions were killed in the name of socialism in the USSR and China, and the countries they subjugated, yet the Left demands no trials, no accountability. Why? Have you ever heard one leftist suggest that Castro should be tried for torturing, murdering, and filling his prisons with dissidents, homosexuals, etc.? Castro is merely making socialist omelets, thus he remains a hero. The reaction to this book by the Left has mostly been to repudiate it as rightist disinformation (despite the fact that the author is on the Left), or to ignore it. Menchu remains a useful myth for those who detest the U.S. and still harbor utopian dreams that require more broken eggs. If your teacher makes you read "I, Rigoberta," read this book as well and ask some hard questions. You will be branded a racist, anti-third world, anti-multicultural, reactionary, but you will at least know the truth and it will set you free . . . especially when you flunk the course!
An iconoclast makes important points. |
69. The Monuments of Piedras Negras, an Ancient Maya City by Flora Simmons Clancy | |
Hardcover: 240
Pages
(2009-03-15)
list price: US$45.00 -- used & new: US$36.00 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0826344518 Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description |
70. The Maya: Life, Myth and Art by Timothy Laughton | |
Paperback: 144
Pages
(2004-03-11)
list price: US$26.85 -- used & new: US$19.98 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 1844830160 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (2)
A beautiful pictorial overview of the Mayan culture At 135 pages, this is not an exhaustive book but rather a brief overview.Readers wanting an in-depth exploration of the culture should look elsewhere.Those who simply have a curiosity about the Mayas, or who love the visual impact of antiquities, will enjoy this book immensely.
Great introductory book on Maya |
71. Handbook to Life in the Ancient Maya World (Facts on File Library of World History) by Lynn V. Foster | |
Hardcover: 402
Pages
(2002-01)
list price: US$70.00 -- used & new: US$52.49 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0816041482 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (1)
Handbook to Life in the Ancient Maya World |
72. The Art of Mesoamerica from Olmec to Aztec (World of Art) by Mary Ellen Miller | |
Paperback: 240
Pages
(1986-03)
list price: US$14.95 -- used & new: US$4.29 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0500202036 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (6)
ready for the trashcan
Waste of time
Successfull challenge
This is very Interesting
Worthwhile but dense Almost of necessity,however, the writing style tends to be fairly dense.Those looking for areadable "History of Mesoamerica" should probably go elsewhere. Nonetheless, most readers will find this book rewarding -- after which theywill want to turn to more specific and detailed volumes by Linda Schele andMichael Coe, among others. ... Read more |
73. Fiery Pool: The Maya and the Mythic Sea (Peabody Essex Museum) | |
Hardcover: 328
Pages
(2010-04-27)
list price: US$65.00 -- used & new: US$40.94 (price subject to change: see help) Asin: 0300161379 Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (5)
Just great
Fiery Pool:The Maya and the Mythic Sea
Fiery Pool: The Maya and the Mythic Sea (Peabody Essex Museum)
Fiery Pool
Extensive, visually intense, stimulating... |
74. Rabinal Achi: A Mayan Drama of War and Sacrifice by Dennis Tedlock | |
Kindle Edition: 382
Pages
(2003-09-04)
list price: US$15.00 Asin: B000WDPKLY Average Customer Review: Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
Editorial Review Product Description Customer Reviews (1)
A Cultural Treasure Tedlock spent many years studying the language, culture, and shamanic traditions of the highland Maya in Guatemala. Together with his wife he underwent a shamanic apprenticeship and later videotaped several performances of this dance drama. This is the only remaining pre-Columbian Mayan play in existence and as such it is a cultural treasure which this transaltor has treated with great respect. The dozens of photographs and line art bring the book alive! ... Read more |
75. | |
Canada | United Kingdom | Germany | France | Japan | |
  | Back | 61-75 of 75 |