Editorial Review Product Description ABOUT THIS BOOK: Korea Unmasked is an illustrated book that presents a hilarious and often unflattering look at Korean society and its people. It brings the reader a fascinating exploration of the Korean mindset and weaves together history, sociology and cultural anthropology. The book introduces an insight in subjects like; Korean history, traditions, culture, food, life, economy, tension between South and N. Korea and more. The book will introduce the reader to Korea and their people and discuss many subjects and attitudes that are sometimes unknown or misunderstood by westerners. The insightful discussions about Korea and differences/similarities with other countries emphasized on the neighbors China, Japan, will help to clear the picture who the Korean people really are. The author, Won-bok Rhie provides a delightful and humorous portrait of the Korean people. It's comical yet serious well-written and informative pictured by the author. If you only have time for one book about Korea, this is the book! ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Won-bok Rhie is one of Korea's most famous cartoonists. After achieved a bachelor's degree in architecture at Seoul National University, he studied graphic design in Germany and obtained a degree of Dipl. Designer. He is the author of numerous comic books introducing historical, cultural and economic subjects. He have also written many comic series in Korea newspapers and magazines. Korea Unmasked is part of a 9-volume series of comic books about several European countries, Korea and Japan, which all became bestsellers in Korea. Rhie is also a professor of graphic design in University in Seoul, Korea. In 1993, he achieved a prestigious Award in recognition of his development and contributions to the Korean cartoon industry. From 1998 to 2000, he also served as the president of the Korean Society of Cartoon and Animation Studies. ... Read more Customer Reviews (6)
Watered down jumping off point - easy on the eyes
For what it is, it's wonderful. One must take into consideration that this is a non-fiction comic book and as such, it takes some liberties in the sake of brevity. We are talking about summing up a whole culture into less than 250 pages. Comments such as "this book is too general" or "it takes too many liberties" failed to see what this book is intended to be - a general overall for people with virtually no background knowledge of Korea. To that end, this book excels.
I also commend this book in its comparison with Japan, China, and America. The author has taken a vast amount of information and condensed it into very approachable subjects such as cultural identity, leadership and economic growth.
Let's not forget that this book is driven by it's artistic style which is quite pleasant and not distracting the least. For an animator, the script is well written and translated which includes very native-English references and subtle jokes that demonstrate his dedication tot he project.
All in all, it's a great non-academic read that is recommended to anyone looking to take an introduction to Korea without having to dig through countless volumes of ancient history and poorly translated, nationalistic rhetoric.
Great artwork, entertaining, unfortunately plagued by ignorance and propoganda - publisher apologized over anti-semetic claims
Great artwork, entertaining, unfortunately plagued by ignorance and propoganda.The book is 9900 Won retail.
Sadly this book is insulting and stereotypical of other cultures, and some of its claims were naeve or absurd to the point that I thought it was comedic satire..until I realized the author wasn't being sarcastic.I'm shocked at some of the ignorant assumptions and outright insults being spewed against other cultures.It's hard to tell which parts are intentional propaganda, and which parts are just ignorance.It shares a lot in common with North Korean texts I've read and Japanese revisionist textbooks, only cuter with cartoon characters and more international anecdotes.
First off, I think Korea has a rich and amazing culture and is a wonderful place and I've visited many times and have many friends both here and in Korea.I learned Korean and traveled every corner of the country and studied its history.It happens that I also think India and about a dozen other countries are great nations and cultures too.My comments only pertain to the outrageous things being said by this book, despite many good things about it.
Early on the book says a lot of things about what all Chinese people believe and why they did everything in their history.Half the time I was laughing, the other time I couldn't believe anyone could be this ignorant.The fact that the author even tries to make these kind of claims speaks for itself.
I noticed it even claims and I quote "China has shown a great deal of tolerance regarding Taiwan".That's funny, for most of the last 50 years China has threatened to invade on a yearly basis.China is about as tolerant as North Korea is of the South.Which I guess isn't a surprise since some South Koreans think that's true too.This claim is basically as outrageous as saying Korea is one country.The book is filled with this ignorance about dozens of countries.
The book simplifies history with childlike logic.For example it literally says that because England is an island like Japan, its people chose to modify foreign cultures a la the Catholic Church to the Anglican church.First of all, this happened because King Henry wanted a divorce and was refused by the Pope, in fact he had 6 wives in his life.It had little to do with the English people or culture (the actual point being made), foreign cultures (what?), or the fact that England is an island.By its own logic if this was the real reason, England would have gotten rid of the Catholic Church a thousand years before it actually did.I'm not going to cover the other hundred claims but this example shows the kind of logic being used.
What's ironic is a lot of claims really apply to Koreans as much as Japan or China.Early on it claims Chinese always think they're the best, when many Koreans think this way as well if not more so.The reality is this is simply a stereotype, and its disingenuous to suggest this is a Chinese stereotype and not a Korean or Japanese one as well.
The author even oversimplifies his own culture.He claims the reason Japan is 1% Christian and Korea 30%+ Christian boils down to Japan being animistic and Korea being shamanistic and animists think there are many gods but shamans think everything is one god.He can't explain the fact that much of Japan converted to Christianity even faster than Korea in the 16th century, until they were literally murdered by the masses or forced to renounce their religion by a military government.Or that many Koreans, even non-Christians, respected Christians for their opposition during Japanese occupation and that Christianity has genuine appeal for many Koreans.
The Korean economic growth is indeed a miracle, a credit to hard work and converging factors.What's insulting is they've dismissed all the other nations and their achievements in broad strokes.It says that since Germany and Japan were already "economic powerhouses" before being demolished in WWII, their economic miracles are anything but.Then it dismisses over a hundred 3rd world countries from comparison by saying it's easy for a third world country to post high growth.Classic.Essentially, the logic of this author is that any country more advanced than Korea isn't worth comparing to for one reason, and any country less advanced than Korean isn't worth comparing to either.
Almost every claim requires an asterisk and fine print.For example, "If you eliminate 75% of countries from consideration, Korea is the most blah blah", or "This has never happened in another country" when it's simply false and should be explained by another asterisk (but not).
The book swerves back and forth between fact and fiction, relying on technicalities.Well if we want to get technical, Korea isn't even a country.There's North Korea, and South Korean.Korea hasn't been a country for almost a hundred years.If you think that's being too technical and callous, try reading what this book has to say about other countries.
The book also makes two puzzling claims that Korea was a vassal was under China and only as a formality, and that Korea is constantly under invasion and the victim of aggressors.That's funny considering even in Korean museums they acknowledge the historical fact that Korea was a vassal of the Mongols and twice invaded Japan under them.These invasions, although failures, were extremely brutal and sadistic and ironically only exceeded by the Japanese invasions of Korea.The fact is Korea was a full vassal and launched joint military strikes as such, and it's pretty malicious to pretend this never happened.What actually happened is pretty generous to Korea - they had little choice but to be vassals and agree to invade with the Mongols and send troops.
Now the book actually has a lot of good content and interesting commentary.It's just constantly mixed in with garbage and propaganda.So I enjoyed a lot of content at the same time as I'd roll my eyes thinking "Oh not this again".The author clearly read the cliff notes of history and filled in the blanks with classic child logic.
The author clearly has talent and a lot of funny things to say.If the author had turned this into satire, it would have worked for a chapter or two until it revealed that this book itself represents the distorted view Koreans have about the world.But it doesn't and goes through pains to explain and qualify itself, and that's why it's not even satire.
Korea is such as wonderful place, even people I've known who went to North Korea tell of how no matter how corrupt the government the good of individuals is hard to defeat.This book is an exception to that, the South Korean analogy to North Korean and Japanese propoganda.
Excellent quick tutorial of the Korean culture
This book (cartoon) is a fabulous introduction to the Korean people and culture. I cannot think of a better introduction, other than going to Korea, of learning and understanding the intricacies of the Korean culture in an entertaining fashion.
This book is not and certainly should not be read as a definitive text. The author's opinions are singular and he offers no counterarguments. Certainly, the author's opinions on various aspects of Koreans, Japanese, and Chinese cultures can be rationally disputed. Nevertheless, they are worthy of contemplation. For example, the author states that Chinese culture emphasizes "oneness", Japanese "peace", and Koreans "fidelity". Although many would dispute this generalizaion, the author's analysis and arguments are very cogent and thoughtful.
The book has highly entertaining cartoons and small jokes which makes it a fun read. I laughed out loud more than a few times reading this informative cultural cartoon.
After readng this book,you will have a far greater understanding of Korea, its culture, and its history, and be refreshingly entertained by the kneeslapping comics and jokes of the author.
This is a good book, but...
This is a decent book, easy to read, and informative for both children and adults. However, it accurately shows the Korean mind in perhaps an unintentional manner. (Not manor! See review below.) Specifically, the Koreans are blind to their own faults and quick to see faults in others, and in comparing themselves to the world the book shows how the Koreans portray themselves and the world. This explains why Koreans are so xenophobic.
I lived in Korea and Taiwan, have traveled in Japan, and was born in Taiwan, and thus I am familiar with Asian cultures. This book insults Japanese or Chinese conformity, and admires Korean conformity.
In many ways even North Korea's extreme form of communishm is a tribute to the Korean ethic of going all out to acheive an end. The book pokes fun at Koreans, yet does not seem to offer criticism of the Korean conformities, how Korean culture has become shallow, and how the Korean mindset is apt to follow blindly any fad, whether it be consumerism or fanatic communism. The book boasts how Korea became democratic in fifty years while it took Western countries hundreds of years. This is just absurd, and it takes a profound ignorance of the West to make such a statement, as well as a simplistic definition of democracy. The book overlooks the South's cruel dictatorships. The problem is the book makes fun of Koreans for things that should be criticized, and admires Koreans for what should be ridiculed.
Koreans are very competitive, but to a fault. Corruption is rampant in Korean society. When I lived in Korea students complained how they had to bribe teachers for everything. One father told me his visually-impaired daughter could not get a seat in front of the class until he gave her teacher a cash 'gift'. Police will take money rather than issue tickets, and this goes all the way up the political ladder.
As to the assertion the book makes as to how different the Korean culture is to the Chinese and Japanese, there is no doubt there is a difference, but subtle, not huge, which the book proudly cries. As to marriage, respect of elders, deference to authority, even taking off shoes indoors, they are very similar, and these are crucial similarities. Size of chopsticks, or use of the spoon, or what sort of bed they sleep in is not that big a difference.I would argue that there are no three cultures separated by language that are so similar than the Koreans, Chinese, and Japanese.
Read this book to get an impression of the way Koreans look at themselves, but bear in mind the book looks at Koreans the way a mother looks at her son.
Excellent guide to Korean culture
Many people often find it difficult distinguish Korean from Japanese, Chinese, and etc. (maybe, in there eyes they are all just 'ASIAN')
This book will clearly educate you on the uniqueness of Korea, Korean culuture and everything related to Korea.
The author provides a nice balanced view. You can see the real 'UNmasked' korea.
This book is supreme for classroom, average reader and even regional specialists.
As far as I know, the author is very renowned professor in Korea.
You will never reget buying this book!
... Read more |